Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Offers Better Value Over Time?

Taking notes on the value of metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles

Choosing between metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles is a big decision for homeowners. Each option offers unique benefits and considerations that can impact the long-term performance and value of your home. Let’s review the key factors to help you make a smart choice that aligns with your priorities and budget!

Durability and longevity

When considering the perfect roof for your home, durability and longevity are important factors. Metal roofing stands out as a top contender, boasting an impressive lifespan of over 50 years on average, with some cases of hundreds of years. This far surpasses the 15–20 year average expectancy of asphalt shingles. Metal’s exceptional resilience against harsh weather conditions like hail, wind, and fire offers unmatched protection for your property. This durability translates to fewer replacements and repairs over time, saving you significant costs in the long run.

A comparison in fading between iron and asphalt
Metal roofs can remain fresh looking for much longer than their asphalt counterparts!

Energy efficiency

When it comes to enhancing energy efficiency in your home, opting for metal roofing is once again the winner. Metal is renowned for its reflective properties, which allow it to deflect sunlight and prevent heat absorption. This, in turn, makes it easy to dial down air conditioning during hot summer months. Additionally, metal can be seamlessly integrated with insulation layers, further improving thermal efficiency and ensuring consistent indoor temperatures year-round.

Also, by lowering your home’s energy consumption, metal roofing contributes to a more sustainable environment and helps increase your home value by making it more appealing to environmentally conscious buyers. On the other hand, asphalt shingles do not provide any particularly notable benefit for energy efficiency. Shingles absorb the heat and transfer it to the attic space.

A fancy red metal roof illuminated by sunlight
Metal roofs can perform perfectly even under the hot summer sun!

Environmental impact

When evaluating the environmental impact of roofing materials, metal roofing emerges as a clear winner in sustainability and eco-friendliness. Unlike asphalt shingles, which contribute to landfill waste due to their limited recyclability, metal materials can be recycled indefinitely. This recyclability factor significantly reduces the burden on landfills and minimizes the environmental footprint associated with replacements. Furthermore, the production process of metal components requires fewer resources and generates lower emissions compared to asphalt shingle manufacturing. So, by choosing metal for your home, you’re investing in a durable and long-lasting solution that’s also sustainable.

Maintenance and upkeep

Unlike traditional roofing materials such as asphalt shingles, which are prone to mold, mildew, and rot, metal is inherently resistant to these issues. This means you can spend less time and money on cleaning and repairs, freeing up your schedule for more enjoyable activities. Likewise, metal requires fewer inspections compared to shingles, thanks to its durability and resistance to damage from weather and pests. Therefore, by choosing metal for your home, you’re investing in long-term peace of mind, knowing that your roof will continue to perform optimally with minimal maintenance efforts.

Insurance premiums

Metal roofs are known for their durability and resistance to damage from extreme weather events, reducing the risk of insurance claims related to roof repairs or replacements. As a result, insurance companies often offer lower premiums for homes with metal roofing, recognizing the reduced likelihood of damages. In turn, by investing in a metal roof, homeowners can enjoy enhanced protection for their property and financial benefits in the form of reduced insurance costs. With insurance premiums being a significant ongoing expense for homeowners, choosing metal roofing is a smart investment! Asphalt shingles simply cannot offer the same level of savings and protection.

Home resale value

The sleek and modern aesthetic of metal roofs adds curb appeal, catching the eye of potential buyers and setting your home apart from others on the market. With the increasing emphasis on energy efficiency and sustainability, more buyers seek homes with durable and eco-friendly features like metal roofing. Investing in a metal roof can lead to higher resale values and quicker sale times for your home. Real estate market data supports this trend, showing that homes with metal roofing installations often fetch higher prices and attract more offers.

Noise reduction

Modern metal roofing systems are engineered with sound-dampening properties that effectively minimize noise from rain, hail, and other external sources. So, by providing a quieter indoor
environment, metal roofs contribute to enhanced comfort and tranquility for occupants. Testimonials from homeowners who have installed metal roofing attest to the noticeable reduction in noise levels, dispelling concerns about disturbances. Similarly, the insulation benefits of metal further contribute to noise reduction by dampening sound transmission from the outside. So, with metal roofing, you can enjoy a peaceful living space free from external noise distractions. This would be impossible with a traditional choice like asphalt shingles!

Warranty coverage

Many metal roofing manufacturers provide extensive warranties, covering materials and artistry for an extended period. Compared to asphalt shingle warranties, which often come with shorter coverage periods and more exclusions, these warranties offer greater assurance. So, by investing in metal roofing with a robust warranty, homeowners can rest assured knowing their investment is protected. Whether it’s protection against manufacturing defects or premature wear and tear, a reliable warranty ensures homeowners can rest easy! This should make it easy to choose between metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles.

Resilience against algae and moss

The resilience against algae and moss is another reason why metal roofing is popular among homeowners. Unlike traditional materials like asphalt shingles, which are susceptible to algae and moss growth, metal is inherently resistant. Metal’s smooth surface and non-porous nature make it difficult for algae and moss to take hold and thrive. This will keep your roof clean and free from unsightly stains and discoloration. With minimal maintenance required to prevent algae and moss growth, homeowners can enjoy the long-lasting beauty and durability of metal roofing. All without the need for frequent cleaning or treatments!

A very nice, and spotless, metal roof
When comparing metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles, the former stays spotless much longer!

Storing valuable roofing materials

Once you have decided on your perfect roofing material, you may find yourself in a situation where you’ve purchased new roofing materials but are not yet ready to begin installation. This can occur due to scheduling conflicts, weather conditions, or delays in securing a roofing contractor. In such cases, it’s vital to have a safe, secure place to store these bulky and often expensive materials. An excellent service provider, Phillips Moving and Storage, offers first-rate short-term storage solutions designed to accommodate large and sensitive items like roofing materials. Utilizing their services ensures that your investment remains pristine, protected from the elements and potential damage until you are ready to proceed with your roofing project.

The result of metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles

The debate between metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles ultimately comes down to your specific needs and preferences. While both options have their merits, weighing factors such as durability, energy efficiency, maintenance requirements, and aesthetic appeal all point to metal as the winner!